We were encouraged not to simply report news like stenographers, but what we wrote should be news. He has worked as an economist with the World Bank, a consultant to the Planning Commission of India, editor of the Indian Express and The Times of India and a Minister of Communications and Information Technology in the Vajpayee Ministry (1998-2004). One is a steady distancing from the external world. She also insisted on teaching him arithmetic. Things have been bad in the lower courts for a long time. If you had what (former US President Abraham) Lincoln called a team of rivals, then you would be hearing more. It means that he wants it to be done fast, like the one who has a beard, Suman!, Does Arun Shourie mind being thought of as a maverick? He studied at Modern School, Barakhambaand and graduatedin Economicsfrom St. Stephen's College, Delhi University. No, Arun; it is for our sake as well; especially, for the sake of all those who have reached the threshold of the temple of ageing from where you speak today. The doorways and aisles of Indian trains are too narrow for wheelchairs. The next day, Shourie tells me that Aditya has been the centre of his universe for 40 years. And ideology is always an instrument for domination. In doing so, Arun has spoken for all of us; for suffering is the substratum of human existence on this beautiful and baffling planet. LSG vs RCB Live Score, IPL 2023: Spotlight on Kohli as Royal Challengers Bangalore aim to bounce back vs Lucknow, Honda's upcoming Creta-rival SUV could be called Elevate, to debut soon, Bhiwandi building collapse death toll rises to eight, Karnataka polls: BJP promises UCC, NRC, special police wing, Harry Potter fan creates art work depicting Benedict Cumberbatch as Voldemort, picture goes viral, Priyanka Chopra reveals why she looks up to Angelina Jolie: 'I think her choices have been so interesting', Kangana Ranaut supports same-sex marriage in India: 'Jab logo ke dil mil gaye hai, hum kya bol sakte hai'. He has written over twenty-five bestselling books.. The First Chapter relates to Arun Shourie's bed ridden wife - Anita's case: of her trials and tribulations when she finds herself as an accused in a trial, for having constructed a farm-house in violation of environmental regulations. Perceptions vary when seen from different angles and Shourie sometimes suffers from tunnel vision. 54.82.85.58 ARUN SHOURIE: The fact that they are voting in a particular way does not justify a particular criterion. "My wife cannot sign a cheque," Arun says with extreme candour. The same thing happened to migrants But could the PM and his secretariat not have foreseen this? The other is renunciation through immersion in it. I had never seen a politician behave so humanely. Political leaders, stalwarts who died in 2020. "How does it matter," he asks, "If I am sacked, say, from The Indian Express, and my tongue is plucked out of me? Or is it not as high as it was in their priority list? But the teaching is, at that time, dont focus on the event. It has taught me that it is a privilege to suffer. VANDITA MISHRA: You are facing a corruption case in a Rajasthan special court. He created a fame as an intelligent, fearless writer and editor who conducted a movement for freedom of the press, uncovered corruption and defended civil rights such that, in the words of Martha Nussbaum, "his dedication to the truth has won admiration throughout the political spectrum". I am not sure of the extent to which he is listened to Secondly, its very good that the CDS (Chief of Defence Staff) has been created. It is because suffering broke and expanded my soul (how else can the soul be expanded?) But the one thing that suffering has done for me is to break the walls of my self-enclosed existence and help me discover a wider family. That would be presumptuous on my part. Nor, he goes on, must parents fall into the trap of wondering when it will become easier, when the chores will end or when the demands placed on them will ease. Has it become collateral damage in the current political scenario? The bubble of human self-sufficiency bursts. In a tone void of any semblance of self-pity, near the end of his story Shourie addresses the worsening of Anitas Parkinsons. So what is absent today? His views on Islamic law saw him attacked by a crowd in Hyderabad, and his book on BR Ambedkar, Worshipping False Gods, provoked some Dalit activists in Pune in the 1990s to pour coal tar over his head. But those, too, were part of the fleeting vanities of life. Jha criticized Shourie's book Eminent Historians, which concerned the NCERT textbook controversies, that it contains "slander" and "has nothing to do with history. Former Justice (J S) Verma, who was the author of the collegium system, had said that it has become a bargaining place On the other hand, if you give the Executive, like the current assertive one, greater authority, you will have an even more disastrous judiciary. The action you just performed triggered the security solution. This enables the people to change the norms. Dark secrets of the sewers of Harappa, CM visits Shivneri on Shivaji Maharaj birth anniversary, Terms of Use and Grievance Redressal Policy. And he certainly would be among the persons who would know these things You dont just have to have an expert, you have to give the expert the confidence I want to listen to your independent advice.. (LogOut/ Elma Smit Wiki, Age, Boyfriend, Husband, Family . Talking to media, Arun Shourie said that CBI decided to register the case in August 2014 based on an anonymous complaint forwarded by Finance Ministry . Also Read: Nirmala Sitharaman interview: Fight us in House, attract smaller parties, keep us under watchbut Cong moving further to fringe. Sometimes, his powerful friends would protest against an item in the newspaper and the proprietor could simply feign ignorance and chastise his editor roundly in front of the complainant. Journalist, politician, and author Arun Shourie has worn many masks. Change), You are commenting using your Facebook account. They are his instruments now. Shourie wrote articles that tried to show that the treatment of women as required by the Quran would in fact offer them protection, although the application of Islamic law in practice was oppressing them. You had no need to. After all, in Mr (PM Narendra) Modis case, he was not elected to continue, he was supposed to change things. I dont give a damn So that is the culmination of a long process. Restoration work at Punes Sassoon hospital: Memorial of Mahatma Gandhis appendicitis surgery to get makeover, Alibabas Jack Ma turns up in Japan as college professor, NEET UG 2023: Tips to ace the toughest section Physics, Shah Rukh Khans son Aryan Khans directorial debut titled Stardom, deets here, Saina Nehwal to skip Asian Games trials due to fitness issues, Some Canadian workers in wage pact with govt to end strike from today, With middle-order under-performing, DC mull Axars batting number ahead of must-win game against GT, US regulator seizes First Republic Bank, to sell assets to JP Morgan, Scuffle over blocking view during IPL match at Arun Jaitley Stadium; no FIR, Anupam Kher recalls love story with Kirron Kher: She was MA first class, I was a simple village boy, Ramnath Goenka Excellence in Journalism Awards, Statutory provisions on reporting (sexual offenses), This website follows the DNPAs code of conduct. "[27][28][29], In 2000, Shourie pledged the entire amount (Rs. That was, incidentally, what Jesus did. But the outcome may be determined by several factors. Arun Shourie worked inthe office of the Minister of Disinvestment, Communication and Information Technology in the government of India. In Photos: Celebrities who announced they are pregnant this year. 'I can no longer escape my nightmares', is Andrew Tate hinting at having panic attacks? India's No. It was a great opportunity to implement the ideas I had written about in the 1960s. So, many things have to be done. But despite their style, the books are obviously the work of a brilliant man, with a wide if idiosyncratic learning, a passion for the freedoms of speech and press, and a desire to get beneath current events to address underlying issues. ( 163 ) $24.99. [1] He developed a reputation as an intelligent, fearless writer and editor who campaigned for freedom of the press, exposed corruption and defended civil liberties such that, in the words of Martha Nussbaum, "his dedication to the truth has won admiration throughout the political spectrum". So it is this regime that is accelerating that process. All these are synonyms for the abating of evil. After BJP was defeated in the general elections of 2009, Arun Shourie asked for reflection and liability within the party. This emboldens me to say one more thing. Although Shourie has never shied away from talking about his son, he has, nonetheless, been surprisingly candid and unflinching in his intimate and moving account of raising him, in his latest and 26th book, Does He Know a Mother's Heart? Mostly, he follows the path prescribed by Buddhist teachers for dealing with difficult situations. The writer, once a hard-nosed journalist who was editor of both the Times of India and the Indian Express in the late 1980s, recalls moving to religion while rushing a frequently ailing Adit to hospital. Arun Shourie on his days at The Indian Express, what's changed since then, what's new about the current establishment, the media's challenges and the weakening of institutions. Arun Shourie's new book offers vignettes of the idiosyncrasies that defined the political class and newsrooms of his time and his journey as an editor through it all. Yet another was a keyboard to allow access to around 50 regularly visited websites on the internet. "Indeed, he cannot stand. In 1975, during The Emergency introduced by the then prime minister, Indira Gandhi, Arun Shourie started working for the Indian Express against what he saw as an attack on civil liberties. Im worried about job losses. Obscenity over the Internet ? In appeal, Rahul says was mistreated, sentenced to attract disqualification, Streaming in May 2023: Dahaad, Fubar, and Saas, Bahu aur Flamingo, Birthday girl Anushka Sharma's audition tape from 3 Idiots left Aamir Khan, Rajkumar Hirani impressed. Science only blocks our ability to feel pain; never overcomes it. I think they may be voting against the alternative and not for the person. Realising the couple would need help in raising Aditya, the maternal and paternal grandparents took up the job. Who can disagree with Arun here? Supreme Court can grant divorce on grounds of irretrievable breakdown o Centre blocks 14 mobile apps used by terrorists, their supporters in J&K. [1], He was nominated from the state of Uttar Pradesh as a BJP representative for two successive tenures in the Rajya Sabha, thus being a Member of Parliament for 19982004 and 20042010. Are you an optimist? VANDITA MISHRA: Do you feel let down by this regime? [23], With the exception of Mahatma Gandhi, he has little time for any religious thinker and, says Nussbaum, his books "nowhere seek to provide balance; nowhere is there a sense of complexity. They include perspective, as being sacked, receiving an award or promotion, or publishing another book is not of the slightest significance to Aditya. VANDITA MISHRA: What are the crises that are special to this regime? Another of his trademarks was deluging a reader with details, analysing documents whether files or rule books or judgments. This edition of Off The Cuff, which saw former minister and author Arun Shourie with ThePrint's Editor-in-Chief Shekhar Gupta, was held in Chennai in July 20. You are more than a compensation for all she has lost. Is it 'nationalisation'? While Indian societys attitude towards the disabled is becoming more compassionate, he finds that the government is still regressive, despite an estimated 40 to 60 million disabled Indians. But Shourie has never wanted to keep Aditya hidden. Much stronger. Arjun Kapoor seems to be a fan of Turkish eggs; heres why you should have them too, IPL 2023 in 360 VR: Immerse yourself in the action with JioDive VR Headset. The problem is in this selection of persons who will be there. They have to be dealt with," Shourie says. She said: I am the mother of a spastic child, and you have written on my behalf., Politics comes second. ARUN SHOURIE: First is the complete throwing away of all norms. In you, her suffering becomes the light of life for a whole lot of people, far and near. asthe son of the Punjabi couple Hari DevShourie and Dayawanti Devasher. The appointment of Mr Jaishankar is a wonderful exception to the norm. [21], Shourie has been described by Christophe Jaffrelot, a political scientist, as "a writer sympathetic to militant Hindu themes"[22] and has publicly voiced support for the aims of the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS), a nationalist Hindutva organisation. Devi Lal, as deputy PM, used the choicest abuses and threats against the newspaper for writing about his son (Om Prakash) Chautalas brazen ballot stuffing in the 1990 Meham by-election. [7][8][9], Shourie is married to Anita, and they have a son. She used to be able to feed herself but her legs now flail so badly that one person has to hold her legs down while another feeds her. The father shouts at the child, curses him. So if a stimulus is required, go in for that. According to Jha, Shourie's thought expressed in the book Eminent Historians, which concerned the NCERT argument, contains "slander" and "has nothing to do with history. It rammed into Anita's little fiat. A woman came up to me at an airport and I thought she was going to talk the usual things about government. Why is this happening? Your IP: I wish you would share yourself with us more often. Not much is known about his family other than the fact that his father was a government employee. That is why the problem is much deeper. [18] As Disinvestment Minister, he led the sale of Maruti, VSNL, Hindustan Zinc among others. A decades-old cartoon of him in a textbook rocked Parliament for days . Goenkas colourful language, replete with expletives and imagery, has been reproduced by the author, who obviously kept detailed notes to illustrate just how canny, courageous and ruthless Goenka was. He joined The Indian Express shortly after the Emergency; the highly stratified hierarchy of the newsroom was a very different place from when he left. But the problem is much deeper than just this regime. Jesus said to Peter: When you are young you girdled yourself and went wherever you wanted. Over the last couple of decades, B.R. That hasnt been our family experience at all," he says, seated in the book-lined study of his home in West End, a tranquil, leafy suburb where Indias elite live behind high walls and riotous bougainvillaea. One night, you decide and carry out demonetisation. Arun Shourie with wife Anita, his mother, Dayawanti Devasher, and son Aditya, who's in the lap of his father, HD Shourie Arun Shourie 's new book is a rumination on death, and also makes sensational revelations about how his father timed his own demise. When and why do you think it has reached the point that it has? Thats true. Dark secrets of the sew Who is a Hindu? Arun talks about transmuting suffering into service. Even if murder has been going on for a long time, that does not justify my murdering anybody today. He shared his life experiences in the 2011-book Does He Know a Mother's Heart: How Suffering Refutes Religion. Ambedkar has come to be idolized as no other political leader has. Power often means the people who are misled on reservation, communalism, lynching and so on. And why have journalists missed the trend? This had just nine keys, like a mobile phone. If you see the falsehoods which have been uttered, I think they are exceeded only by (US President Donald) Trump. And China is a disruptive power. I invited you to inaugurate the Global Leprosy Summit in Delhi some years ago. previous 1 2 next . I know this could sound insensitive, given how preoccupied you are with things at home. In the temple of suffering, we are fellow worshippers. His wife meanwhile refused to meet with spiritual gurus as her "hopes were raised again and again, and again and again they are shattered." But finally one day, Krishnamurti invited them to his. Shourie remains calm, avoiding the sort of rage, resentment and bitterness that can overcome parents with special needs children. It prompts him to question God's ways and infer a few eternal truths, which to the writer are strangely comforting. He joined hands with Arun Shourie Indian Express chairman Ramnath Goenka for a crusade against Dhirubhai Ambani's Reliance Industries. Restoration work at Punes Sassoon hospital: Memorial of Mahatma Gandhis appendicitis surgery to get makeover, Alibabas Jack Ma turns up in Japan as college professor, NEET UG 2023: Tips to ace the toughest section Physics, Shah Rukh Khans son Aryan Khans directorial debut titled Stardom, deets here, Supreme Court to hear on May 8 plea challenging Anand Mohans premature release, Saina Nehwal to skip Asian Games trials due to fitness issues, Some Canadian workers in wage pact with govt to end strike from today, SC adjourns hearing on Chhattisgarh govts plea challenging PMLA, With middle-order under-performing, DC mull Axars batting number ahead of must-win game against GT, US regulator seizes First Republic Bank, to sell assets to JP Morgan, Scuffle over blocking view during IPL match at Arun Jaitley Stadium; no FIR, Anupam Kher recalls love story with Kirron Kher: She was MA first class, I was a simple village boy, Ramnath Goenka Excellence in Journalism Awards, Statutory provisions on reporting (sexual offenses), This website follows the DNPAs code of conduct. Arun Shourie - The World of Fatwas Or The Sharia in Action (2012, Harper Collins) To begin with, the rulings of the jurists show that the husband has the total, absolute, unbridled power to tell his wife, 'Unless you do "X",' or, in the alternate, 'Unless you refrain from doing "Y",' 'you are divorced'. What kind of government says that we cannot pay compensation because we dont know how many migrants died? When I ask him if differences of opinion are ever an issue with his brother-in-law Suman Dubey, a friend and advisor to first Rajiv and then Sonia Gandhi, he answers: Theyre absolutely irrelevant. Arun Shourie on his tale of cerebral palsy and enduring love The Indian economist and former politician has written a reflective book about life with a severely disabled but dearly beloved son. [11], He is skeptical of religions and especially the concept of organised religion. Then the night comes. Arun talks also about the vanity of titles and entitlements. It is to look at ourselves and get to know the mind better. The government has in the foreign minister an experienced diplomat who possibly knows what is happening. Independence does not mean being contrary. Minimum government, maximum governance is just a slogan., Is Shourie being disingenuous when he criticizes the provocative statements and silences of BJP leaders in the run-up to the Bihar elections? Shourie looks at the ceiling. I thank my friend: PM Modi to Bill Gates for appreciating Mann Ki Baat. He deplored factionalism within the party and those who brief journalists to aid their own agenda. Can gay marriage be part of Hindu cultu Can gay marriage be part of Hindu culture? Shourie jokes he was the only editor with the distinction of being sacked twice from the same newspaper. Here Arun takes us into the heart of human sorrow from where we may take a measure of all human vanities. Im absolutely astonished the Prime Minister would go so far just for one state election. But another personal loss accelerated the spiritual journey. Answer Writing Exercise(CPC-1) Broad Guidelines for a Model Answer. Behind the barbed-wire writings is a man with a cause, a solitary chronicler holding up the mirror to degenerate political values. shelved 12,664 times. [1] He became a fellow of the Indian Council of Social Science Research in 1976. I was impressed. by. ARUN SHOURIE: Not at all. Nalini Singh's brother, Arun Shourie . that I cannot belong exclusively to any group or enclave. I could not hold back my tears when I heard these words. There is an event that I cannot help recalling on this occasion. Im not worried about GDP going down So (its about) useful production, and error remediation of the environment, creation of infrastructure, better thought out infrastructure in the Himalayas, rather than converting Kedarnath and Badrinath into Chardham Yatra and destroying the ecology of the place. So you have to work hard in converting adversity into a learning opportunity or better growth. Suman usually does things very quickly, his photography or whatever, and if Adit wants something done immediately, he will do like this . Shourie scrapes a long index finger along his jawline. And they are swept away by the small little things an official car, being saluted There is a misperception today that Mr Modi is mindful of the RSS. What led to the violence in Manipurs Churachandpur before CM N Biren Singhs visit? Adversity breaks down many people. He was honoured with the Padma Bhushan by the UPA Government in 2009 for his contribution to journalism. [6] Arun Shourie speaks about his personal life and reviews his life events as case diaries "My writing is like the case diary of an advocate which is aimed at winning a case" and his opinions on journalism. Soon after the incident, Anita began to feel peculiar sensations on her left side. He complained competition within the party and those who brief journalists to benefit their own programs. ARUN SHOURIE: There are two very distinct ways. Yet he laughs you can hear his laughter three houses away. Aditya looks at me and raises his left arm. In his fathers words in his book Does He Know a Mothers Heart?, on religion and suffering, He cannot walk or stand. One is Gandhijis way he was immersed till his last breath. We have to work hard at it. Parents of special needs children in India tend not to talk about them in public. Arun Shourie rocked the rather staid Indian newspaper world back in the Seventies and Eighties. "[26], Historian D.N. But it is not just throwing money and saying I have given the stimulus package. . We prefer trinkets to truth. Critics of Shourie who view him as a hypocrite, a betrayer, a sour man angry not to have been given a job in government, may underestimate his obstinacy. ARUN SHOURIE: You could be angry. For example, since it is hard for Aditya to hold a cup or drink from it, he runs the risk of swallowing too much. A profile on the media's lone crusader and his work. No one can feel the quality, or gauge the magnitude, of your suffering. Shourie says that these gadgets make a big difference to people. As a cabinet minister overseeing information and technology, Shourie campaigned on behalf of improved access for the disabled, efforts that were abandoned by his successors after he left office in 2004. For instance, those days, I was quite upset. Atal Behari Vajpayee, when he became prime minister in 1998, made Arun Shourie a Rajya Sabha MP and a minister, managing disinvestment and revolutionising Indias telecom industry. VANDITA MISHRA: In your latest book, Preparing for Death, there are two strands of renunciation. THE QUESTION THAT poses itself as you make your way through Arun Shourie's memoir, The Commissioner For Lost Causes, of his days as a journalistand the decided superstar he was in the 1980s, face of the fantastic stories of The Indian Express ranging from purchasing a girl and exposing slavery to bringing down a chief minister for corruptionis "There must be some reason God has done this," he says. He wants to shake your hand. The father strokes the sons face, helping him to move his head. So, we should be humble. Yet Shourie and Anita have travelled all over India with their son; eating out in restaurants is one of Adityas great loves. Arun shourie, former union Minister, economist, journalist, author and social activist. That is what the child will need as he grows up a net of love and security." VANDITA MISHRA: You have provided a great perspective on the decline of the courts.